Public vs. Private University

The choice between a public and a private university to study economics is a crucial decision that can significantly impact your academic and professional future. This article provides a detailed analysis of the differences between these two types of institutions, so you can draw your own conclusions and make your decision without concerns.

Matteo Casali

7/19/20247 min read

Costs and Scholarships

Public Universities

Public universities in Italy are state-funded, allowing them to offer relatively low tuition fees. However, the variability in costs is significant and depends on the student's family income. At the University of Bologna, tuition fees for the Faculty of Economics are based on the ISEE (Equivalent Economic Situation Indicator). Students with an ISEE below 23,000 euros pay a reduced fee of about 157 euros. However, for students with an ISEE below 13,000 euros, fees can be completely exempt thanks to the full exemption program. Conversely, students with an ISEE above 70,000 euros can pay up to 3,300 euros per year. This graduated fee structure helps maintain access to higher education for lower-income families.

Scholarships

Public universities offer several scholarship programs through the DSU (Right to University Study). For example, at the University of Florence, in 2023 about 35% of students received a DSU scholarship. These scholarships cover not only tuition fees but also expenses for accommodation, transportation, and educational materials. Additionally, scholarships can be awarded based on merit, ISEE, and socio-economic status.

The University of Turin, with its "Polo" scholarship program, supported over 5,000 students in 2023, fully covering tuition fees and providing a contribution for other expenses. This program is accessible to students with an ISEE below 25,000 euros, demonstrating public universities' commitment to ensuring access to education for students from low-income families.

Private Universities

Private universities in Italy, such as Bocconi University in Milan and LUISS Guido Carli in Rome, have significantly higher costs. At Bocconi, tuition fees for the Faculty of Economics amount to about 13,000 euros per year, with additional costs for materials and services. LUISS Guido Carli, located in Rome, has a similar annual cost, which can exceed 12,000 euros. These costs may vary slightly depending on the course of study and other variables. Despite the high cost, these universities offer a wide range of scholarships and financial aid.

Scholarships

Private universities, although having high fees, offer substantial scholarships. At Bocconi, the "Bocconi ISU" program provides scholarships based on both merit and financial need. In 2023, about 25% of students who applied received a full or partial scholarship. However, competition is high: for the merit-based scholarships, about 1,000 students out of 4,000 received financial support.

At LUISS Guido Carli, the "Excellence and Merit" program offers scholarships to students with excellent academic performance and demonstrated financial need. In 2023, about 30% of enrolled students received a scholarship, but only 20% of applications based on financial need were accepted, reflecting the high competitiveness and the large number of requests.

The average annual cost of an Italian private university exceeds 12,000 euros, while that of a public university is about 1,500 euros, although this may increase for students with higher incomes. Scholarships at public universities are more widespread and accessible, but often only cover tuition fees. Private universities, despite having more competitive scholarships, offer greater financial support but to a smaller percentage of students.

Quality of Teaching

Public Universities

Public universities in Italy offer a wide range of courses and study programs, generally with a more theoretical focus. However, the quality of teaching can vary greatly due to the resources available.

Student/Teacher Ratio

The student/teacher ratio can be unfavorable at some public universities. For example, at the University of Milan-Bicocca, the ratio is about 1 teacher for every 30 students. This can affect the quality of interaction between students and teacher and the personalization of the learning path.

At the University of Rome La Sapienza, the ratio is similar, with a high number of students per faculty member. Despite its high academic reputation, the approach to classes may be less personalized compared to institutions with smaller class sizes.

Private Universities

Private universities tend to have smaller classes and a more favorable student/teacher ratio, allowing for more individual attention and personalized teaching.

Student/Teacher Ratio

At Bocconi, the student/teacher ratio is about 1 to 10, allowing for more personalized attention. Smaller classes enable students to interact more directly with the teacher and receive more immediate feedback.

LUISS Guido Carli has a ratio of about 1 to 12, with classes that encourage interaction and discussion. This approach facilitates a more dynamic and engaging learning environment.

Private universities often achieve higher ratings in teaching quality, with average scores of 4.3 out of 5 for private university students, compared to 3.8 for public universities, as reported in a 2022 European Commission study. This reflects the difference in resources invested and class sizes.

International Opportunities

Public Universities

Italian public universities offer various international opportunities through exchange programs and collaborations with foreign universities. Opportunities may vary based on partnerships and available funds.

Erasmus and Other Programs

The University of Padua, for example, has agreements with over 500 universities worldwide. Partner universities include the University of Oxford, the Sorbonne University of Paris, and the University of Melbourne. In 2023, about 15% of students in the Faculty of Economics participated in international exchange programs like Erasmus. This program allows students to spend a study period abroad and earn credits recognized in their degree course.

The University of Turin has initiated exchange programs with over 300 universities worldwide, including Stanford University and the University of Amsterdam. In 2023, 20% of students participated in international exchanges, demonstrating the accessibility and commitment to internationalization.

Private Universities

Private universities tend to offer a more extensive international network and a greater variety of exchange opportunities. These universities have agreements with prestigious institutions and offer double-degree programs and international internships.

Erasmus and Other Programs

Bocconi University, for example, has partnerships with over 280 universities in 54 countries, including agreements with prestigious institutions such as Harvard University and the London School of Economics. These collaborations offer exchange opportunities, double degrees, and international internships. LUISS Guido Carli has agreements with over 300 global universities and offers double-degree programs with universities such as Georgetown University and the University of Hong Kong. About 30% of LUISS students participate in international programs each year.

At Bocconi, about 40% of students in the Faculty of Economics participate in international exchange programs, highlighting a strong commitment to internationalization and global preparation.

Private universities tend to offer a greater variety of international opportunities compared to public universities. About 30% of private university students participate in international exchange programs, compared to 15-20% of public university students. Private universities often collaborate with more prestigious institutions and offer more diversified programs.

Internship Opportunities

Public Universities

Italian public universities offer internship opportunities through collaboration programs with companies and organizations. However, access to these opportunities can vary based on the university's resources and professional connections.

Companies and Collaborations

The University of Bologna, for example, has collaboration agreements with several companies, including Ferrari, Unicredit, and Eni. However, the number of available internship positions can be limited, and competition can be high. In 2023, about 20% of students in the Faculty of Economics completed an internship through these programs.

The University of Pisa has initiated partnerships with companies like Google and Deloitte, offering internship opportunities to about 25% of students. However, access to these opportunities depends on resource availability and the university's ability to establish and maintain collaborations with companies.

Private Universities

Private universities, thanks to their corporate connections and alumni network, generally offer better internship opportunities. Prestigious companies often collaborate with these universities to provide internships and networking opportunities to students.

Companies and Collaborations

At Bocconi, students have access to a network of over 1,000 partner companies, including McKinsey & Company, JPMorgan Chase, and IBM. Bocconi also offers a career counseling service that helps students find internships and job opportunities. In 2023, about 50% of students in the Faculty of Economics completed an internship at prestigious companies.

At LUISS Guido Carli, students can access internship opportunities at companies like PwC and BCG. LUISS also organizes networking events and career days to connect students with employers. About 45% of students in the Faculty of Economics completed an internship through these opportunities in 2023.

Private universities tend to have a larger and better-established network of partner companies compared to public universities. This translates into greater availability of internships and networking opportunities for students. In 2023, about 50% of private university students completed an internship, compared to 20-25% of public university students.

Infrastructures and Resources

Public Universities

Italian public universities often have limited resources compared to private universities. Facilities can vary greatly depending on public funding and resource management.

At the University of Bologna, for example, facilities may include classrooms and laboratories that are not always state-of-the-art, due to limited funds for renovations and updates. However, the university has invested in new buildings and study spaces in recent years.

The University of Naples Federico II has recently renovated some buildings, but many of its facilities are still outdated. This can affect the learning experience and the availability of modern technologies.

Private Universities

Private universities tend to invest significantly in their infrastructures, offering modern and well-equipped study environments.

At Bocconi, the campus features modern buildings with technologically advanced classrooms, co-working spaces, and sustainable facilities. Bocconi is known for its commitment to environmental sustainability and has received international recognition for its low carbon footprint, as indicated by the Financial Times, which ranked it as the world's first university for carbon management.

LUISS Guido Carli has recently inaugurated a new campus with innovation laboratories and collaborative learning spaces, offering students a stimulating and modern study environment.

A 2023 report by the Ministry of Education highlighted that 75% of private universities have modern laboratories and technologically advanced classrooms, compared to 50% of public universities. This reflects the greater financial resources available to private universities and their commitment to offering a high-quality learning environment.

Conclusion

The differences between public and private universities in the Faculty of Economics are substantial and affect various aspects of students' academic and professional experiences. Public universities offer more affordable costs and a wide range of scholarships, making higher education more accessible to students from diverse economic backgrounds. On the other hand, private universities offer often superior teaching quality, with smaller classes and a more favorable student-faculty ratio, allowing for more personalized attention and direct interaction.

International and internship opportunities are another determining factor. Private universities tend to have a wider and more prestigious network of collaborations, offering students greater global exposure and better chances of entering the job market. However, public universities are also improving in this field, thanks to numerous international agreements and exchange programs.

Ultimately, the choice between a public and a private university depends on your personal priorities, available financial resources, and academic and professional goals. Carefully analyzing all these aspects will allow you to make an informed decision and take the first step towards a successful career in economics. Regardless of your choice, both public and private universities offer valuable opportunities for a comprehensive education and adequate preparation for future challenges.